Our build-your-own cheddar package gives you the freedom to create a personalized cheddar sampler. Complete steps 1 – 3 by selecting an age and size for each and receive a 10% discount. Try a vertical tasting (medium - extra sharp) or maybe a comparison of our smoked, clothbound, and block cheddars – you decide!
Product Cost
Select 1st Cheddar
Select 2nd Cheddar
Select 3rd Cheddar
10.00% Discount

Select 1st Cheddar

2-Year Cheddar
(Extra Sharp)

Our Extra Sharp Cheddar is our best known cheddar. Aged for a minimum of 2 years, this cheese has the classic Vermont cheddar cheese profile...acid forward sharpness, some minerality, and sweetness on the back end. Great to snack on any time of year, but especially during apple picking season and deep winter days.
  • 1/2 lb 2-Year Cheddar (vacuum-sealed)
  • $12.00
  • 1/2 lb 2-Year Cheddar (waxed block)
  • $14.50
  • 1 lb 2-Year Cheddar (waxed block)
  • $24.00
  • 2 lb 2-Year Cheddar (waxed block)
  • $41.00