Our build-your-own cheddar package gives you the freedom to create a personalized cheddar sampler. Complete steps 1 – 3 by selecting an age and size for each and receive a 10% discount. Try a vertical tasting (medium - extra sharp) or maybe a comparison of our smoked, clothbound, and block cheddars – you decide!
Product Cost
Select 1st Cheddar
Select 2nd Cheddar
Select 3rd Cheddar
10.00% Discount

Select 1st Cheddar

1-Year Cheddar

After about a year of aging, the buttery grassy flavors of our younger cheddar give way to the delightfully acidic finish of our Sharp Cheddar. This cheese melts wonderfully and provides a robust flavor note in your favorite recipes.
  • 1/2 lb 1-Year Cheddar (vacuum-sealed)
  • $10.50
  • 1/2 lb 1-Year Cheddar (waxed block)
  • $12.00
  • 1 lb 1-Year Cheddar (waxed block)
  • $21.00
  • 2 lb 1-Year Cheddar (waxed block)
  • $38.00